Credit card or prepaid card: which one to choose to better manage your money?
Credit card vs. prepaid card
When opening a bank account, one question often comes up:
đ Should you choose a credit card or a prepaid card?
For many people, the difference seems minimal. However, these two cards function very differently and can have a significant impact on your finances.
In my opinion, for someone who wants to better manage their budget, avoid unnecessary debt, and progress towards financial freedom, The prepaid card has several advantages.
In this article, we will look at:
- The difference between a credit card and a prepaid card
- The advantages and disadvantages of each solution
- Why prepaid cards reduce the risk of debt
- Which card to choose based on your profile
What is a credit card?
A credit card allows you to spend money even when it is not immediately available in your bank account.
In reality, this card allows the customer to go into debt to make purchases.
In concrete terms:
- You are making a purchase today
- The bank pays the merchant
- You pay back to the bank later
The bank is therefore giving you temporary credit. That's actually where the name "« credit card ».
For example :
You buy a computer for 1,500 CHF with your credit card.
The bank advances the funds. A few weeks later, you receive the bill and you have to repay the amount.
On the other hand, you can imagine that if the bank lends you money, it's because they can make money. We'll analyze this later.
What is a prepaid card?
A prepaid card works in exactly the opposite way.
You must have the money before you can spend it.
The principle is simple:
- You add money to your bank account
- You only spend the money available
- When the balance is empty, payments are declined.
In other words:
đ It's impossible to spend more than you own.
The majority of modern digital banks in Switzerland now use this model.
For example :
- Yuh
- Neon
- Zach
- WIR Top
The main difference
| Prepaid card | Credit card |
|---|---|
| Use your own money | Temporarily uses bank money |
| It is not possible to spend more than the available balance. | Possibility of spending more than your balance |
| No debt possible | Possible debt |
| Easier budget control | May encourage overconsumption |
đ The fundamental difference is therefore the risk of indebtedness.
Why can credit cards be a problem?
A credit card isn't inherently bad. The problem often stems from human behavior.
When the money leaves your bank account immediately, you feel the expense more.
With a credit card, the pain of payment is postponed.
This can give the impression that the purchase costs less than it actually does. This is obviously a false impression.
Numerous studies in financial behavior show that consumers generally spend more when using credit rather than cash, because they think less about the financial consequences.
The trap of deferred repayment
The trap of deferred repayment
Let's take a simple example.
You are going on holiday and the total cost of your stay is:
- Hotel: 700 CHF
- Restaurants: 300 CHF
- Activities: 400 CHF
Total: CHF 1,400
If you have to pay these 1,400 CHF with your own money in advance, you will probably compare hotels, look for discounts, choose some budget-friendly activities and seriously consider your travel budget.
Perhaps you will even decide to postpone this vacation if you find that it is beyond your means.
For what ? Because you immediately feel the true cost of the expense and you immediately understand the future financial consequences.
Example
Now, let's imagine that you are offered:
âYou only pay 100 CHF per month with interest.â
Suddenly, 1,400 CHF seems much more affordable.
Your brain no longer sees the total price. It focuses solely on the monthly payment.
You tell yourself:
â100 CHF per month isnât much, I can afford it.â
That's precisely where the trap lies.
Ease of payment reduces the immediate pain of the purchase and often encourages spending more.
Ultimately, you will:
- Paying additional interest or fees (i.e., your vacation will be more expensive than paying upfront yourself)
- Spend more during your trip since the cost seems less important.
- Accumulating multiple monthly payments from other purchases.
- Seriously increase your risk of debt.
The most dangerous aspect is that the repayment continues long after the end of the vacation.
Once your vacation is over, the memories are already behind you. But your bank keeps asking you every month for the money it advanced, plus interest to payâŠ
To conclude:
đ The ease of payment gives the impression that a purchase is cheaper. But it's the opposite, because you will pay additional interest.
đ The payment plan allows you to spend money you don't yet have. But it will force you to tighten your belt in the following months.
In my opinion, when a seller emphasizes the monthly payment more than the total price, you should generally refuse!
Comparison: Investing vs. Going into Debt
When people talk about consumer debt, most immediately think of lost interest.
However, in my opinion, the true cost is often much higher.
Every franc used to repay a debt is a franc that is not invested in building your wealth.
Let's take a simple example.
Let's imagine two people who each have 5,000 CHF.
The first person decides to invest these 5,000 CHF in the stock market in a diversified ETF with an average return of 7% per year.
The second person uses these 5,000 CHF to buy consumer goods on credit.
Here's what happens after 10 years:
| After 10 years | Person A: Invests CHF 5,000 | Person B: Spends CHF 5,000 on credit |
|---|---|---|
| Initial amount | 5,000 CHF | 5,000 CHF |
| Use of money | Stock market investment | Consumer purchase |
| Average annual yield | 7 % | 0 % |
| Value after 10 years | â 9,835 CHF | 0 CHF |
| Interest paid | 0 CHF | â 500 CHF |
| Value of the property purchased | / | â 0 CHF |
| Final Heritage | + 9,835 CHF | â 5,500 CHF |
In the end, the investor has almost 10,000 CHF.
The person who went into debt no longer owns anything from their initial purchase and has even lost money with interest and the loss of value of their belongings.
đ The wealth gap between the two people then exceeds 15,000 CHF.
And yet, they had exactly the same starting amount.
Why prepaid cards are interesting for a frugal person
Frugalism involves controlling one's spending in order to save and invest more.
The prepaid card fits perfectly into this logic.
Why? BecauseâA prepaid card naturally imposes financial discipline.
You cannot spend:
- Next month's money
- Your future salary
- A reserve that you do not possess
You only spend what is actually available. This has several positive effects:
- Significantly reduce impulsive purchases.
- Limit the risk of overconsumption.
- Prevent the creation of unnecessary debt.
- Becoming more financially responsible
The advantages of a prepaid card
Here are the main advantages:
Better budget control
You know immediately how much you have left.
No risk of debt
It's impossible to spend money you don't have.
Simplicity
No complex monthly bill to analyze.
Reduction of impulsive purchases
Each purchase is financed with your own money.
Less financial stress
No unpleasant surprises at the end of the month.
The advantages of a credit card
Although I prefer prepaid cards, credit cards sometimes have certain advantages.
Easier bookings
Some hotels or rental agencies prefer credit cards. In these cases, a prepaid card may not be sufficient.
For example, if you rent a car, there is a very good chance that the rental agency will want to block the deposit with your credit card.
For a frugal person, in my opinion, this is the only useful thing to have a credit card. That is, to tie up money for rentals.
So, which card should I choose?
A prepaid card is undoubtedly the best option!
It's the simplest card for becoming thrifty and managing your money. Furthermore, it helps you avoid debt.
In summary, a credit card is often unnecessary, but it may be wise to have a no annual fee credit card for situations where prepaid cards are not available.
Conclusion
The difference between a credit card and a prepaid card is simple:
đ The credit card allows you to spend money from the bank.
đ The prepaid card only allows you to spend your own money.
For someone looking to save, invest and build wealth, the prepaid card has a major advantage:
It significantly reduces the risk of debt.
And when seeking financial freedom, avoiding consumer debt is often more important than finding the perfect investment.
Sometimes, The best investment is simply avoiding a bad financial decision.
FAQ: Credit card or prepaid card: which one to choose to better manage your money?
What is the difference between a credit card and a prepaid card?
A credit card allows you to pay with money advanced by the bank, then repay later. A prepaid card only allows you to spend the money available in the account. The main difference, therefore, is the risk of debt.
Can a prepaid card help avoid debt?
Yes. Since it is impossible to spend more than the available balance, a prepaid card greatly reduces the risk of going into debt for consumer purchases.
Why do credit cards sometimes encourage overconsumption?
Payment is deferred. Many people focus on the monthly bill rather than the total cost of their purchases, which can encourage impulsive spending.
Are prepaid cards suitable for people who want to save money?
Yes. Prepaid cards allow for better budget control, limit impulsive purchases and facilitate the management of daily expenses.
Can a prepaid card be used for online purchases?
Yes. Most modern prepaid cards allow you to pay online, in physical stores, and even abroad, depending on the bank's terms and conditions.
What are the advantages of a prepaid card for a frugal person?
A prepaid card helps to stick to one's budget, avoids consumer debt, reduces financial stress and promotes saving as well as long-term investment.
Is a credit card always bad?
No. A credit card can be useful for certain specific situations, such as booking a hotel, renting a car, or making certain payments that require a deposit.
Why can monthly payments be misleading?
Monthly payments often give the impression that a purchase is affordable. However, they mask the true total cost and may include interest or additional fees.
Does a prepaid card allow for better budget management?
Yes. Each purchase is directly linked to the money actually available, making expenses more visible and easier to track the budget.
Do you need to have a credit card and a prepaid card?
For some people, this combination can be advantageous. The prepaid card is used for everyday expenses, while the credit card is kept for reservations requiring a guarantee.
Do banks make money from credit cards?
Yes. Banks can charge annual fees, commissions on payments and especially interest when the account holder does not repay their bill on time.
Which bank card should I choose to avoid impulsive purchases?
A prepaid card is generally the best option. Since it only uses available funds, it encourages more thought before each purchase.
Is a prepaid card safer than a credit card?
Both cards generally benefit from similar security systems. However, a prepaid card limits the amount that can be used in case of fraud, as it does not allow spending beyond the available balance.
Can a prepaid card help you become more financially disciplined?
Yes. Many people develop better financial habits when they only use money they actually have.
What type of bank card should I choose to build my wealth?
For someone looking to save, invest, and avoid consumer debt, a prepaid card is often the most suitable solution. It promotes responsible money management and reduces long-term financial risks.
Credit card or prepaid card: which one to choose to better manage your money?
Subscribe for the latest news
You have a frugalist or minimalist project and you want a training? Click âhereâ.
My pages
- About me
- Saving / Frugalism
- Blog
- Shop
- Contact
- Training and E-book
- Invest
- Minimalism
- My account
- Newsletter
- Basket
- Order confirmation
Lastest Post
- 2nd pillar: The basics to understand
- Top 5 tips to make money from home
- How to invest 1200 CHF â Simplified version
- How to invest on a small budget?
- REIT: Investing in Passive Real Estate
How does this blog live?
Overall, this blog lives on sharing a frugal and minimalist lifestyle.
For a question of transparency towards the readers. All recommended products are in order to make life cheaper, simpler and to promote the essentials.
Basically, my only income with this blog comes:
- Trainings that I realize
- Promo codes for the products I use
- Donations that readers make in exchange for neutral information.
About me
I decided to create this blog to develop and help readers who are looking for a simpler and more economical life.
Compared to before, I was a person who consumed a lot until the day I realized that my consumption made me sadder and poorer đ
Now I prefer the minimum of my needs to be happy and achieve my financial freedom.
Without realizingI started to focus on saving and investing to depend on a boss for as little time as possible and to speed up my personal projects.
For several years I have felt happy and I have become richer in a way that I would never have imagined given that I have an average salary in Switzerland.
It is for this purpose that I decided to create this blog. In order to share and learn with other people who seek freedom and simplicity đ
Are you rather minimalist or frugal Jonny?
I am as minimalist as I am frugalist. However, there are situations where I lean more towards an art of life.
To conclude, I think the most important thing is to feel comfortable in your lifestyle đ
Consumer debt: why it's a trap for your assets
Credit card or prepaid card: which one to choose to better manage your money?
Leave a Reply